Stop Optimizing Hotels – We Want Character!

Walk into any newly built or renovated chain hotel right now, and the feeling is almost identical from one city to the next.

Bring-back-hotels-with-character

It’s even the same across countries.

Here’s the formula: you get a wide lobby that is beige, softly lit, and arranged expensive-looking furniture, but has no actual feeling of comfort.

The rooms, too, often follows the same playbook, with the same gray-toned headboard, the same framed abstract print, the same modernized bathroom with good lighting and very little soul.

Everything is technically fine, which was their aim in the first place, yet almost nothing lingers in your mind during your stay or after you checkout.

That sameness is the real problem in 2026.

Hotels used to play a large part of your actual vacation. They gave your destination a texture, a mood, a story you could carry home.

A mountain lodge might have rough timber beams, odd little reading corners, and a stone fireplace. Or, a beach motel might have turquoise railings and shell lamps that constantly reminded you that you are by the water and on vacation.

Even properties that were not fancy could still feel alive. They had personality. They made you feel something.

Now, by contrast, many newly built hotels from big brands seem engineered first for frictionless operations and brand consistency. That approach is, of course, easy to understand from the corporate angle.

It is cheaper to repeat details, simpler to standardize maintenance, and safer to avoid design choices that could upset somebody.

Still, a vacation is not run like a business.

Travel is supposed to loosen routine and place you inside an environment that feels a bit richer than your ordinary life. When every property looks like it was designed by a committee trained to fear color, what do we have to look forward to from our accommodation?

More stylish and quirky hotels make vacations better because they turn the stay into part of the fun.

A beautifully strange inn with hand-painted tiles, a dramatic staircase, mismatched antique chairs, and a courtyard bar can shape the mood of an entire weekend.

Even a roadside property can do it. The best charming hotels create atmosphere before a guest even opens the room door. They make people want to linger, take photos, notice details, or even give you a sense of nostalgia.

In fact, that emotional residue is often what guests remember most clearly.

What has gone missing, apparently, is the idea that a hotel can be slightly impractical, a little theatrical, and still deeply successful. Not every property needs to become a museum piece, and not every room needs oddball furniture that hurts your back.

We know comfort and cleanliness matters. Yet, character matters, too, and the industry has, more or less, acted as if charm were an optional extra instead of a core reason people enjoy travel in the first place.

When Did Hotels Stop Being Cool?

There was a time when the hotel itself was part of your trip’s narrative.

You might arrive at a desert motor lodge with sun-faded stucco walls, a neon sign that had survived three different decades, and a lobby full of regional art that nobody had cleared away.

You might check into a city hotel where the hallways were richly patterned, and the bar downstairs had the low glow of a setting people actually wanted to spend time in.

We think this aura was especially alive in the 80s and 90s, but slowly started to get “modernized” in the mid 2000s.

Many new chain properties today are being built to reassure guests that nothing surprising will happen.

The room will be efficient. The outlets to charge your precious phone will be plentiful. The finishes will be neutral enough to offend no one and delight almost no one.

There is, of course, a market for that. Business travelers often want predictability. Families on a road trip sometimes want speed and quiet rather than design experimentation.

Even so, hotels have gradually allowed predictability to swallow personality altogether.

That shift has changed how vacations feel today. Travel has become more transactional at the large chains as the hotel offers only utility.

A charming property invites wandering. A generic one encourages sleeping and leaving.

In a memorable hotel, guests notice the tilework, the vintage postcards on the wall, the creaky library door, or the timeless courtyard fountain. In a highly optimized hotel, guests mostly notice where the ice machine is and whether the mobile key worked.

With the rise of private equity and painstaking adherence to maximizing shareholder value, the 2020s have seen this trend hit overdrive.

Interchangeable New Hotels

Why are they building every hotel the same these days?

We believe the first reason is brand uniformity.

The hotel industry has been consolidating more and more and large hotel groups now manage dozens of flags, and each flag usually comes with a prescribed visual system.

Designers are often working inside a box long before they sketch the first room. Approved furniture lines, approved color palettes, approved materials, approved lighting concepts, approved lobby layouts, all of that creates a safe end product that can be replicated from Nashville to Phoenix to suburban New Jersey.

Consistency, from the corporate viewpoint, reduces risk.

The second reason is development economics. Building a hotel is expensive, and owners understandably want predictable returns. Distinctive architecture, custom furnishings, local craftsmanship, and richer decorative programs usually cost more than standardized packages purchased at scale.

So, many developers choose finishes that are easy to source, easy to replace, and easy to explain to lenders. The result is a wave of properties that are, basically, assembled from the same visual vocabulary. Gray oak-look flooring, black metal accents, matte fixtures, abstract art, platform beds, and public spaces that could sit almost anywhere.

The third reason is operational simplicity. Unique hotels require more thought once they open. Vintage furniture needs care. Unusual layouts may challenge housekeeping. Richer fabrics and layered décor can create more cleaning demands. Distinctive public spaces need staff who know how to animate them.

It is usually easier to run a property that has fewer design flourishes and more standardized surfaces. Optimization, in other words, rewards whatever is easiest to maintain and repeat.

The fourth reason is algorithmic marketing.

Hotels are now sold heavily through online listings, brand sites, and travel apps. That environment encourages spaces that read quickly on a screen. A room must look bright, crisp, and legible in a small image. Fine-grained personality is harder to communicate in a split second.

Developers often build for the booking photo rather than the in-person feeling. That is why so many new rooms look good enough online but strangely bland when you stand inside them.

Finally, there is fear.

Truly distinct design makes choices, and choices create strong reactions. A hotel with bold wallpaper, eccentric artwork, dramatic colors, or regionally rooted architecture might be adored by some guests and disliked by others. Many chains would rather avoid that tension. So they aim for broad approval and land in an aesthetic middle that feels clean and competent.

It is far worse to not get a 15% return on your investment than take a chance and either make a unique success or fail.

What Charming Hotels Do Better

Hotels with character improve a vacation because they create emotional contrast from normal life.

Most people do not travel to feel as though they have checked into a larger, nicer version of a generic apartment complex.

They got that back home already.

They travel to feel lifted out of their routine. A hotel with genuine style helps trigger that shift immediately.

You immediately notice the scent in the lobby, the music in the bar, the architecture of the courtyard, the humor in the signage, and the local art on the walls.

Those little things shape your memory as strongly as the city or beach outside.

Charming properties also encourage guests to stay present. In a distinctive hotel, people often slow down.

You’ll find them sitting in the lobby longer. They order a second drink. They read on the terrace. They take the long way back to their room because the hallway or garden or staircase is pleasant.

In a generic hotel, the room is often just a holding area between outside activities. You’ll find people at the bar, but it’s just the same bunch of boring businesspeople who are forced to interact since they have nothing else to do.

Character also builds a stronger sense of place.

A hotel in Santa Fe should not feel like a hotel in Charlotte. A coastal California stay should not be visually interchangeable with an airport corridor property outside Chicago.

When design reflects local materials, history, climate, or quirks, travelers absorb more of where they are.

What are some example?

You can have thick adobe-inspired walls, rattan and tropical prints, mountain stone, lake-house porches, art deco references, citrus tones, or Gulf Coast tones and breeziness to really emphasize a local feeling.

There is also simple joy in staying somewhere that has a point of view.

Travel should include a bit of play. A funky motel with old-school signage and a great pool deck can be more fun than a spotless new tower with no personality at all.

A historic inn with odd corners and charming imperfections can be more satisfying than a perfectly efficient room that could belong to any chain in any state.

Style, when done well, gives a trip flavor.

Good and Examples Across the USA

Across the US, there are plenty of examples that show the divide clearly. In Palm Springs, for instance, many smaller retro-inspired hotels and renovated mid-century properties understand exactly what travelers want from this chic desert oasis.

They use color, geometry, landscaping, vintage references, and pool culture to create a full atmosphere. The best ones feel playful without becoming a theme park. You arrive, and the property immediately tells you where you are.

That is smart design.

By contrast, some newly built select-service chain hotels in fast-growing Sun Belt markets feel as though they were copied from a universal template, regardless of if it’s from Marriott, Hilton, or IHG.

What do you get? An exterior that is boxy and anonymous. A lobby with gray seating and warm tones. A room that has a wallpaper accent behind the bed and not much else.

Nothing is terrible, but nothing is memorable. The stay could take place in Texas, Arizona, or inland Florida with almost no visual difference.

In New England, older inns and small coastal hotels succeed because they allow regional texture to remain visible.

You can find shingled exteriors, creaky wood floors, nautical touches used with restraint, old portraits, layered libraries, and porches that actually invite sitting. These details create warmth. Even renovated properties can keep that spirit alive if the work respects age instead of scrubbing everything into blandness.

Meanwhile, certain newer chain properties in the same region seem reluctant to acknowledge place at all. Aside from perhaps one photograph of a harbor, the interiors could belong to any suburban business district.

In the Southwest, the contrast can be even sharper. Some really design-forward properties in Santa Fe, Tucson, and parts of New Mexico use earth tones, handcrafted elements, courtyards, textured plaster, local art, and dramatic light in ways that feel rooted and atmospheric.

They make the climate and landscape part of the stay.

Yet, plenty of newer chain hotels in those same broader regions flatten everything into corporate minimalism.

In the South, especially in cities with old building stock such as Charleston, Savannah, and New Orleans, character-rich stays often come from preserved architecture and a willingness to embrace eccentricity. Wrought iron balconies, interior courtyards, patterned floors, moody bars, and a bit of decorative excess can create real charm.

On the other side are new-build chain properties with the exact same interiors that feel assembled exclusively for corporate travelers. They function, yes, though they do not deepen the destination.

Mountain states show a similar split. A good lodge-style property uses timber, stone, layered textiles, fireplaces, porches, and scale in a way that feels cozy rather than corporate.

A boring version imitates that look with printed carpet, fake rustic lighting, and mass-market furniture arranged around a lobby fireplace. Guests know the difference almost instantly, even if they do not describe it in design language.

The Problem with Sameness

Sameness creates a subtle fatigue. After enough identical corridors, enough neutral rooms, and enough lobbies with coworking furniture, travelers stop expecting delight.

The hotel risks becoming an appliance, and that is not a small cultural loss.

Hotels have long been stages for fantasy and romance. They are where people celebrate anniversaries, take family trips, and begin honeymoons. They make travel feel different from everyday life.

When hotel design is reduced to efficiency, those emotional layers thin out. The industry may still produce attractive spaces, and many of them are objectively comfortable, but comfort alone does not create attachment.

Nobody returns home talking passionately about a beige lobby with a communal worktable and a market pantry near the check-in desk.

In fact, travelers often forgive minor imperfections in a charming property because the stay feels alive. A room might be smaller. The building might creak. The bathroom might not be enormous. Yet, if the atmosphere is rich and the design has personality, guests often remember the experience fondly.

A generic property does not receive that same grace. If all it offers is smooth efficiency, then every flaw becomes more noticeable because there is no emotional upside to offset it.

Why Chains Keep Moving This Direction

To be fair, chains are responding to real pressures. They need to satisfy owners, investors, brand managers, franchisees, and a massive range of guests.

Standardization lowers costs and shortens decision-making. New hotels also have to meet modern expectations around technology, accessibility, energy performance, and maintenance.

It is easier to deliver them through repeatable systems than through highly individualized design.

There is also the problem of speed. The hotel industry now moves fast, and development pipelines reward efficient replication. Once a brand finds a prototype that performs well, it often multiplies that prototype across markets.

What gets lost, though, is the idea that a hotel should absorb something from its street, city, landscape, and history.

Another issue is that many brands now use the language of authenticity without actually taking the creative risks required to achieve it. A property may include a mural by a local artist, a few regionally themed books, and a menu item named after the neighborhood, yet the overall experience remains generic.

The branding suggests place, while the architecture and interiors tell a different story.

How to Improve New Hotels

Bringing back hotels with character does not require abandoning comfort or turning every property into an experiment in design.

It means designing with more courage and more local intelligence. A new hotel can still have excellent mattresses and efficient bathrooms while also having rooms that feel distinctive.

They can deploy local materials, source some meaningful art, use regional color, add some layered textures, and provide some more interesting lighting that responds to their climate and context.

Chains, too, could loosen their grip on total sameness. They could allow for more regional variation within brand standards, like different color palettes for New York vs Florida.

They could commission more local artisans and source more design elements from the communities where they build. They could create public spaces that encourage hanging out rather than simply circulating traffic.

Ultimately, they should trust that guests are capable of enjoying a little personality.

Developers could also learn from successful boutique hotels and revived motels that understand how strong visual identity builds loyalty. People recommend those properties not only because the service was good, but because the stay felt like something. That feeling turns into word of mouth, repeat visits, social sharing, and a sharper brand impression.

The industry does not need more hotels that look optimized for a render. It needs more hotels that give travelers a sense of occasion.

More color. More regional influence. More playful lobbies. More courtyards. More bars with mood. More buildings that feel as if they belong to the community.

We find that vacations are simply better when the hotel contributes to the pleasure of being away.

So, the case for bringing back hotels with some character is not nostalgia for its own sake. It is a reminder that travel should feel different, and hotels are a major part of making us feel that.

We deserve places with identity and charm. We deserve a life with identity and charm!